This may be a bit of a stretch, but stick with me. My cousin, who's a bit older, a bit wiser, has been emailing with me lately about jobs and so forth. This advice, in particular, keeps bouncing around my head:Do what you got to do, but my advice is shoot for a place that allows you to build your ideas not talk about them. That’s why I didn’t like journalism (tearing down ideas) or politics (manipulating others’ ideas).
So that was on my mind when I was trying to figure out why the media were just relentlessly haranguing Dirk Nowitzki, blaming him for all of the Mavs' ills in this series with Golden State when it had been, until last night's close win, a total team failure. As I mentioned a couple posts ago, the world is gushing and gushing about Baron Davis as he passes to one-time no names like Matt Barnes, who's been knocking down threes all series. Then they turn around and just kill Dirk for passing out of double- and triple-teams to proven veterans like Jerry Stackhouse, who's shooting around 30 percent for the series. This is Dirk's fault?
But if you think, like most everyone does, that Dirk is the MVP, then it all makes sense. The idea of Dirk-as-MVP is an easy idea to latch on to and tear down (or it was easy until his heroics last night).
Just check out these quotes, not just from hacks on Around the Horn (except you, Michael Smith), but from some of the better reporters in the sports biz.
From the AP:For the first 236 minutes of the playoffs, Dirk Nowitzki was little more than a bit player for the Dallas Mavericks.
Then he made his presence felt in a big way -- the way the league's likely MVP is supposed to do.
From Mark Stein: "Yet it turns out that three minutes, for the likely MVP-to-be, is still a lot of time, even after roughly 237 minutes of misery, confusion and frustration in his Round 1 nightmare."
And, in typical overblown fashion, Bill Simmons (hiding behind a fake David Stern voice):You (Dirk) didn't just fail to step up like an MVP should, you whined and complained the entire series, disgraced your teammates and embarrassed your fans. ... I don't know whether to hand you this trophy or smash it over your head. Lucky for you, this is being televised, so I can only hand you the trophy and congratulate you on the 2006-07 Most Valuable Player Award. I'm going to leave now so I can throw up.
Look, Dirk was not dominating like I expected him to either. But these are guys who get paid to observe and analyze this sport, so I thought maybe they would entertain the argument that Dirk was making the right basketball plays. If you've ever played the sport, it was easy to see that Dirk made the right passes just about all series. If his teammates had hit their shots (like they did all season), Dallas might have won this series already. Then we'd hear non-stop about how Nowitzki changed his game to help his team win. But his teammates didn't, and tearing down Dirk's MVP award is the easiest and most obvious story line to latch on to as a way of explaining the Mavs's loss.
(An aside: If that's the definition of MVP — best player at single-handedly creating and making his own ridiculously tough shot in the clutch — let's just give the award to Kobe every year and forget about it. I’d rather play with the guy who passes.)
Not to mention, the writers could talk how the Warriors are playing on a different plane right now. Not even Phoenix can boast an eight-man rotation with seven legitimate three-point threats. Coupled with the Warriors newfound ability to defend, they've been incredible to watch. My friend Tom described it best: "They're like a pack of wolves." Never mind all that, though, let’s criticize Dirk.
Last night he found himself single-covered down the stretch, and he scored like 12 of the Mavs' final 15 points. Nellie's not going to let that happen again in Oakland. And when he makes the right pass, it's going to come down to whether his teammates come through. Maybe that's not an MVP, I dunno. But it's worked pretty well for Tim Duncan and his three rings.
(All that said, I think the energy in in Oakland is too high for the Mavs right now. Golden State will move on and sweep Houston.)Labels: basketball, journalism, NBA